← ButtHurt NYC — The Real Talk Blog

Slip and Fall in NYC? It's Not Funny — Here's What to Do

By James Medows, Esq. · June 20, 2026 · 5 min read

Okay, the name got a grin out of you. Fair. But a real fall — on a broken sidewalk, a wet store floor with no sign, an icy stoop nobody salted — is no joke when you're the one icing a wrist or missing work. Here's how these claims actually work in New York, minus the legalese.

When someone else may be on the hook

Property owners in New York have a duty to keep their space reasonably safe. If a hazard caused your fall and the owner knew about it (or should have), you may have a premises-liability claim. The classics: unmarked wet floors, broken steps, bad lighting, and ice or snow left too long.

What helps your case

About "partly my fault"

New York uses comparative negligence, so even if you were partly at fault, you can usually still recover — your share just reduces the amount. Don't talk yourself out of a claim before someone who knows the rules looks at it.

Related reading

ButtHurt NYC is an intake and referral service from the Law Office of James Medows. Mr. Medows doesn't personally handle injury cases; with your written consent we connect you with an experienced injury attorney, and a referral never increases your total fee. General info, not legal advice — and the wink is the name, nothing more.

Took a spill that wasn't your fault? Free case review — we'll tell it to you straight.
Call (844) JAMES-07
James Medows, Esq. — second-generation criminal defense attorney, Brooklyn NY. 20+ years of courtroom experience, 1,500+ five-star Google reviews. A defense attorney, never a former prosecutor.

Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This article is general information, not legal advice.